Child & Youth Care Forum Гуманитарные и социальные науки

Parental Academic Expectations Across Cultures: A Qualitative Comparison of Motivational and Emotional Experiences Among High-Achieving Adolescents in the United States and China

Qiao, Joy, Diener, Marissa
Springer Nature · 2026-11-14 · DOI 10.1007/s10566-026-09991-8

Аннотация

Background From a Self-Determination Theory perspective, the motivational significance of parental expectations may depend on how adolescents interpret and experience them, yet few studies have examined these experiences across cultural contexts. Objective This study examined how high-achieving adolescents in the United States and China described parental academic expectations, how their parents communicated and encouraged them to meet those expectations, and their own motivational and emotional experiences. Methods Semi-structured interviews with 34 students aged 11–13 years (19 U.S., 15 Chinese) were analyzed using a hybrid deductive and inductive thematic approach informed by Self-Determination Theory. Results Participants in both samples described high parental expectations and substantial parental involvement, yet their descriptions of expectations and parental motivational practices varied across the samples. Chinese participants more often described specific standards, close monitoring, and an emphasis on continuous improvement within competitive academic environments. A motivational paradox emerged in their accounts: enjoyment of academic challenges often coexisted with pressure and anxiety. U.S. participants more often described broad expectations, praise, and encouragement, together with confidence and satisfaction with their performance. Accounts also varied within each sample. Conclusions Findings suggest that high parental expectations took on differing motivational and emotional meanings across the two samples. These contrasting accounts highlight the importance of attending to adolescents’ subjective interpretations of parental expectations within cultural contexts.

Читать у издателя →