Knowing when to quit: experience, binding financial constraints, and withdrawal from new venture creation

Shane, Scott
Small Business Economics · Springer Nature · 2026-10-07 · DOI: 10.1007/s11187-026-01281-w

Abstract

Why do people quit the startup process before a business is formed? We treat withdrawal from new venture creation as a test of Evans and Jovanovic’s ( 1989 ) model of liquidity constraints at the pre-entry margin. In the model, constraints bind when desired capital deployment exceeds what personal finances can support. We test three predictions with Entrepreneurship in the Population (EPOP) Survey data from 2023 to 2025, comparing 3980 responses from continuing nascent entrepreneurs with 6903 responses from people who considered or pursued a business and then stopped. Experienced founders report deploying more than twice the startup capital of novices. The association between pre-existing financial constraints and stopping is stronger for experienced founders. The experience gap in stopping odds is large at one financial constraint, marginal at two, and no longer detectable at three. A further implication, that funding-rationed seekers stop at higher rates, is directionally positive but not robust across years. The results are consistent with liquidity constraints binding at the pre-entry margin and help reconcile weak wealth-entry relationships with evidence that constraints matter. Most Americans who consider or work toward starting a business stop before the business exists. Using 3 years of a national survey, we ask who stops and why. People who had previously started businesses put more than twice as much money into their attempts as first-timers. Because they put more money in, the same financial weaknesses, thin savings, poor credit, or no banking relationship, weigh on them more heavily. Experienced founders otherwise have much lower odds of stopping than first-timers, but that gap narrows as financial problems stack up, and among people facing all three problems we can no longer detect it. Founders with these problems are especially likely to name money as the main reason they stopped. Aspiring founders should judge financial readiness against the size of the business they want to build. For policymakers, financial capacity matters most for experienced founders, who put in the most money.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles