Journal of International Business Studies Strategy and Management

Populism, regime characteristics, and MNC location choice

Jandhyala, Srividya, Kunczer, Vera, Lindner, Thomas
Springer Nature · 2026-10-01 · DOI 10.1057/s41267-026-00878-3

Abstract

Los países con gobiernos populistas son destinos de inversión menos atractivos para las multinacionales, ya que las empresas extranjeras tienden a ser deslegitimadas y tratadas como actores externos. Sin embargo, los gobiernos populistas varían en la medida en que deslegitiman a las empresas extranjeras como forasteras. Alejándose de la clasificación tradicional de derecha-izquierda que oculta diferencias clave entre los regímenes políticos, este artículo investiga aspectos centrales del populismo y cómo los gobiernos populistas perciben a las empresas extranjeras: la orientación proempresarial y la postura sobre la inmigración. Los regímenes proempresariales perciben un mayor papel para las empresas del sector privado y tienen menos probabilidades de tratar a las multinacionales como actores externos. Sin embargo, los regímenes con una postura restrictiva frente a la inmigración destacan las amenazas a la identidad local y tienen más probabilidades de tratar a las multinacionales como actores externos. Utilizando una base de datos de más de 23,000 inversiones extranjeras directas (IED) en 61 países anfitriones entre 2008 y 2017, encontramos que el efecto adverso del populismo sobre la IED se reduce en los regímenes proempresariales. Además, el efecto adverso del populismo se amplifica en los regímenes con posturas fuertemente antiinmigración, mientras que la alineación entre los regímenes del país de origen y el país anfitrión disminuye el impacto negativo de los gobiernos populistas sobre la IED. Nuestra investigación destaca el papel crucial de las características del régimen en la configuración de la IED en contextos de gobiernos populistas. Países com governos populistas são destinos de investimento menos atrativos para MNCs, pois empresas estrangeiras tendem a ser deslegitimadas e alvo de ataques por serem vistas como integrantes de um grupo externo. No entanto, governos populistas variam no grau em que deslegitimam empresas estrangeiras como forasteiras. Partindo da classificação tradicional entre direita e esquerda, que oculta diferenças importantes entre regimes políticos, este artigo investiga aspectos centrais do populismo e como governos populistas enxergam empresas estrangeiras: orientação pró-negócios e posição em relação à imigração. Regimes favoráveis ao negócio reconhecem um papel maior das empresas do setor privado e são menos propensos a tratar MNCs como membros de um grupo externo. No entanto, regimes com uma postura fortemente anti-imigração destacam ameaças à identidade local e são mais propensos a tratar MNCs como membros de um grupo externo. Utilizando um conjunto de dados com mais de 23.000 investimentos estrangeiros diretos (FDI) em 61 países anfitriões entre 2008 e 2017, descobrimos que o efeito adverso do populismo sobre FDI é reduzido em regimes favoráveis a negócios. Além disso, o efeito adverso do populismo é amplificado em regimes com posturas fortemente anti-imigração, enquanto o alinhamento entre os regimes dos países de origem e de destino reduz o impacto negativo de governos populistas sobre o FDI. Nossa pesquisa destaca o papel crucial das características dos regimes na configuração dos fluxos de FDI sob governos populistas. 拥有民粹主义政府的国家对跨国公司(MNC)的投资吸引力较低,因为外国公司往往被剥夺合法性,并作为外来群体成员而被针对。然而,不同的民粹主义政府在将外国公司视为外来者并剥夺其合法性的程度上存在差异。本文摒弃了传统的左右翼分类——这种分类掩盖了不同政治体制之间的关键差异——转而聚焦于民粹主义核心方面,以及民粹主义政府如何看待外国公司的两个问题:商业导向和移民立场。亲商体制认为私营企业应发挥更大作用,因此较不可能将MNC视为外来群体成员。然而,持有强烈反移民立场的体制则会强调对本地认同的威胁,因此更可能将MNC视为外来群体成员。通过使用2008至2017年间61个东道国中超过23,000项外国直接投资(FDI)的数据集,我们发现,在亲商体制中,民粹主义对FDI的负面影响有所减弱。此外,在反移民立场强烈的体制中,民粹主义的负面影响会被放大;而当母国与东道国的体制一致时,民粹主义政府对FDI的负面影响则会减轻。我们的研究突出了体制特征在塑造不同民粹主义政府下FDI流动中的关键作用。 Countries with populist governments are less attractive investment destinations for Multinational Corporations (MNCs), as foreign firms tend to be delegitimized and targeted as members of the outgroup. However, populist governments vary in the extent to which they delegitimize foreign firms as outsiders. Departing from the traditional right–left classification that masks key differences among political regimes, this paper investigates aspects central to populism and to how populist governments see foreign firms: business orientation and stance on immigration. Pro-business regimes perceive a greater role for private sector firms and are less likely to treat MNCs as members of the outgroup. However, regimes with a strong anti-immigration stance highlight threats to local identity and are more likely to treat MNCs as members of the outgroup. Using a dataset of over 23,000 foreign direct investments (FDI) across 61 host countries from 2008 to 2017, we find that the adverse effect of populism on FDI is diminished in pro-business regimes whereas it is amplified in regimes with strong anti-immigration stances. Furthermore, regime alignment between home and host countries reduces the negative impact of populist governments on FDI. Our research highlights the crucial role of regime characteristics in shaping FDI across populist governments. Multinational companies often decide where to set up operations based on a country's political environment. Populist governments, which divide society into "the people" and "the elite," can create uncertainty for foreign firms by creating insiders and outsiders. This study explores why some foreign firms still invest in countries with populist regimes. It suggests that the perception of foreign firms as outsiders depends on the host country's business orientation and stance on immigration. Business orientation refers to how much a regime supports private-sector firms, while immigration stance indicates how a regime views foreigners entering the country. Pro-business regimes are more welcoming to foreign firms, while anti-immigration regimes view them as outsiders. The study also considers how alignment between the political regimes of the home and host countries affects investment decisions. It uses data from 23,795 foreign investments made by 5187 firms from 77 countries between 2008 and 2017. The study compares these with potential investments that were not made, using statistical models to analyze the data. The research focuses on two key aspects of political regimes: business orientation and immigration stance. The results show that foreign firms are 28% less likely to invest in countries with highly populist governments. However, this negative effect is weaker in pro-business regimes and stronger in anti-immigration regimes. Further, alignment between the host and home countries plays a significant role. The study highlights the importance of understanding specific dimensions of the political environment when making investment decisions. This text was initially drafted using artificial intelligence, then reviewed by the author(s) to ensure accuracy . Les débats de longue date persistent quant à l'impact des nouvelles technologies sur les entreprises, en particulier en ce qui concerne l'internationalisation. Certains chercheurs suggèrent que la numérisation renforcera les avantages des activités d'exportation en facilitant les connexions avec les partenaires et les clients. D'autres, en revanche, estiment que la numérisation ne sera tout simplement pas à la hauteur des attentes, voire qu’elle aura des conséquences encore plus néfastes. Ce débat est particulièrement pertinent pour les PME, étant donné que l'activité d'exportation constitue pour elles la principale voie d'accès aux marchés mondiaux. Nous proposons que la numérisation exercera des effets doubles sur les PME : d'un côté « lumineux », des investissements plus importants dans les technologies numériques conduiront à une activité d'exportation accrue (c'est-à-dire des ventes à l'exportation plus élevées) ; d'un côté « sombre », cependant, l'activité d'exportation induite par la numérisation générera moins d'opportunités d'apprentissage auprès des partenaires d'exportation (c'est-à-dire des gains de productivité plus faibles). Les hypothèses proposées ont été testées et confirmées à l'aide de données détaillées au niveau de l’entreprise, issues d'un panel de 20133 entreprises portugaises entre 2010 et 2019. Des analyses supplémentaires et des études de cas corroborent les mécanismes proposés, et suggèrent des approches hybrides comme une solution possible pour équilibrer ces effets doubles de la numérisation. Ensemble, ces résultats apportent un éclairage nouveau sur le débat concernant le rôle de la numérisation dans les efforts d'internationalisation.

Read at publisher →