Relationship between information technology governance (ITG) and firms’ performance: systematic literature review and meta-analysis
Аннотация
To examine the relationship between ITG and Firms’ performance based on the Previous literature. ITG is classified into four segments, and Firms’ performance in the two segments. Previous studies’ results evaluate using the Meta-Analysis methodology to find the relationship between ITG and firms’ performance. Analysis of the result suggests that the ITG strategy strongly correlated with the firm’s performance based on R-value and P -value. The finding also suggests that the heterogeneity in the relationship between ITG and firms’ performance is very high. Based on the literature review, it is suggested that future researchers build a model for establishing the relationship between ITG and Firms’ Performance. Organisations have been making greater investments in IT, but the board of directors and executives are receiving mixed messages about which ITG practices merit such investments. Some studies have found significant improvements in organisational performance as a result of ITG practices, while others have found no significant effects. This creates a gap in practice, where the issue remains unresolved as to which ITG practices merit the organisation’s governance investment and how much of the differences found in the literature reflect actual performance differences versus differences in research designs. The first search using Scopus yielded 1372 articles. However, after screening, 394 articles fulfilled the criteria for inclusion in the systematic review, while 67 studies ( N = 20,760 participants) were selected for the meta-analysis and meta-regression. Generally, the findings show that ITG is moderately positively related to firms’ performance ( r = 0.46, 95% CI [0.38, 0.52]), although heterogeneity is extremely high (I^2 = 97.63%, Q = 2790.25, p < 0.001). According to the subgroup analysis, Board ITG, ITG Strategy, ITG Measurement, and Executive ITG have similar effect sizes for their associations with performance ( r = 0.44 to 0.47, overlapping confidence intervals), indicating that none of these constructs can be distinguished from the others in terms of significance. However, it distinguishes among concepts of reliability, with board ITG, ITG strategy, and ITG measurement being highly consistent in study settings. At the same time, Executive ITG demonstrates considerably greater heterogeneity across studies, meaning that while it provides the greatest value on average, it is much more unpredictable at the level of individual cases. Meta-regression shows that the type of measurement, rather than the method of analysis or use of control variables, significantly moderates effect size estimates. All this means that the major source of disagreement in the field of interest is not actual differences in the effect of ITG but different methodologies employed. It can be stated that Board ITG, formal ITG Strategy, and ITG Measurement provide organisations with a predictable return on their governance efforts. This paper ends with a methodological agenda for future ITG research and practical advice for practitioners.