Robots Are Us

Journal of Youth and Adolescence · Springer Nature · 2026-10-12 · DOI: 10.1007/s41549-026-00144-3

Abstract

Will smart (programmed) machines do to humans what the internal combustion engine did to horses—render them obsolete? If so, can putting people out of work or, at least, good work leave them unable to buy what smart machines produce? The answer, as we illustrate in a simple, two-period, two-good life-cycle model, is yes. Our goods are output and prayers. Output is produced with code, new and legacy, and capital. This function is effectively a robot with code for brains and capital for brawn. ”Robots are Us” captures our key assumption that code is the offspring of human brains, specifically that of high-skilled agents. Such agents are free to produce new code or pray (for others). Low-skilled agents only pray. An improvement in code tech, modeled as greater durability, increases current demand for (and supply of) new code. But it decreases future demand. What explains this dynamic reversal of Say’s Law? When code lasts longer, today’s fresh code means even more legacy code tomorrow. But tomorrow’s greater legacy code reduces tomorrow’s need for/demand for new code and, thus, coders. Hence, a code-tech shock generates a boom-bust cycle in the coders’ wage, which, thanks to skilled-worker mobility equals their prayer wage. Output, saving, and investment boom and bust in unison with wages. The investment bust can leave the economy’s capital stock and, potentially, output and lifetime utility below their starting values. Such immiserating growth is more likely when code can, as AI now does, self improve. Whether or not future generations are worse off, the big winners are early generations who ride the boom and avoid the bust. As we discuss, cross-cohort redistribution can share the gains from tech shocks and preclude immiseration. What about limiting IP rights? Surprisingly, doing so makes immiseration more likely. Better tech worsening the economy? This is as counterintuitive as Leamer (1999)’s finding that a minimum wage can raise GDP and lower inequality. Both studies pull rabbits out of hats, which was Edward Leamer’s lifetime practice and delight.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles