Methods and metrics to support sustainable sourcing programs of major grain crops. A review
Аннотация
Increases in food production must be sustainable, i.e., respectful of the environment, profitable for farmers, and improve human conditions. Companies sourcing agricultural commodities are uniquely positioned to shape global sustainability outcomes by influencing producers’ decisions, yet current sourcing initiatives are fragmented and may not enable a true transformation toward more sustainable crops. Our objectives were to characterize current sustainable commodity sourcing programs, identify methods and metrics for program support, and synthesize results on sustainability indicators for four major crops (wheat, Triticum aestivum L.; rice, Oryza sativa L.; maize, Zea mays L.; and soybean, Glycine max (L.) Merrill). Five major business models emerged among current sustainable sourcing programs: practice-based, outcome-based, carbon-credit, commodity-premium, and performance-based. The majority of the programs were practice-based or hybrid, with outcome- and performance-based requiring substantially greater verification. Among the scientific literature across four major crops, a majority of studies addressed production and environmental or economic indicators, while fewer examined human or social aspects. The translation of research findings to field applications seems limited by the initial cost of adoption (monetary and human capital), technology availability, and education. Future research should (1) include end-use quality parameters and grain nutritional components in sustainability assessments and (2) increase the robustness of small-scale assessments of social and human condition sustainability. To achieve meaningful impact, sustainable sourcing programs should adopt transparent assessment frameworks to evaluate suppliers using measurable environmental and social indicators, incentivize sustainable practices through premiums, and invest in farmers’ capacity and access to technology. They should also integrate social criteria, e.g., labor conditions and nutrition, collaborate across supply chains to harmonize standards and reduce duplication, and prioritize circular, resilient systems that enhance long-term sustainability. Together, these actions can shift sourcing from a compliance exercise to a catalyst for more resilient, equitable, and sustainable crop production.