Journal of International Business Studies Strategy and Management
The dual effects of digitalization on SMEs: export gains and learning losses
Abstract
Longstanding debates persist about the impact of new technologies on firms, particularly as it relates to internationalization. Some scholars suggest that digitalization will enhance the benefits of export activity by facilitating connections with partners and customers. Others, however, suggest that digitalization will simply fail to live up to the hype—or perhaps even worse. This debate is especially relevant for SMEs given that export activity is the primary route to global markets for such firms. We propose that digitalization will exert dual effects on SMEs: on the “bright” side, larger investments in digital technologies will lead to greater export activity (i.e., higher export sales); on the “dark” side, however, digitalization-induced export activity will generate fewer learning opportunities from export partners (i.e., smaller productivity gains). The proposed hypotheses were tested and supported using detailed firm-level panel data from 20,133 Portuguese firms from 2010 to 2019. Additional analyses and case studies corroborate the proposed mechanisms and point to hybrid approaches as one possible way to balance these dual effects of digitalization. Taken together, the findings shed new light on the debate about the role of digitalization in internationalization efforts. Debates de longa data persistem sobre o impacto das novas tecnologias nas empresas, particularmente no que diz respeito à internacionalização. Alguns acadêmicos sugerem que a digitalização aumentará os benefícios da atividade exportadora ao facilitar conexões com parceiros e clientes. Outros, no entanto, sugerem que a digitalização simplesmente não corresponderá às expectativas — ou talvez seja ainda pior. Esse debate é especialmente relevante para SMEs, dado que a exportação é a principal via de acesso aos mercados globais para essas empresas. Propomos que a digitalização terá efeitos duais sobre as SMEs: pelo lado “positivo”, maiores investimentos em tecnologias digitais levarão a uma maior atividade de exportação, isto é, maiores vendas de exportação; pelo lado “negativo”, entretanto, a atividade de exportação induzida pela digitalização gerará menos oportunidades de aprendizagem com os parceiros de exportação, isto é, menores ganhos de produtividade. As hipóteses propostas foram testadas e confirmadas com base em dados detalhados em painel ao nível das empresas, abrangendo 20.133 empresas portuguesas entre 2010 e 2019. Análises adicionais e estudos de caso corroboram os mecanismos propostos e apontam para abordagens híbridas como uma possível forma de equilibrar os efeitos duais da digitalização. Em conjunto, os resultados esclarecem um pouco mais o papel da digitalização nos esforços de internacionalização. Firms, especially small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), are increasingly adopting digital technologies to enhance their international business operations. These technologies, such as cloud-based systems and AI-driven tools, help firms manage processes and engage with international markets more efficiently. While digitalization offers benefits like reduced costs and expanded market reach, scholars debate its overall impact, suggesting both positive and negative outcomes. This study examines how digitalization affects export activities, focusing on its dual effects: increased export activity and decreased learning from export partners. This article investigates the impact of digitalization on export activities using data from 20,133 Portuguese firms between 2010 and 2019. The study uses firm-level management and accounting data to analyze the effects of digital investments on export intensity and productivity. Digitalization is measured by investments in software and technology. The study employs a two-stage regression analysis to assess how digitalization influences export activity and learning-by-exporting. The research finds that digitalization boosts export activity by enabling firms to identify and connect with new trade partners. However, it also reduces opportunities for learning from these partners due to less rich human interactions. The results show that digitalization leads to higher export activity but limits the learning benefits typically gained from exporting. Firms that invest in digital technologies experience increased export intensity but gain less productivity from these exports compared to firms not using digitalization. This dual effect highlights the "bright" side of digitalization, which enhances export capabilities, and the "dark" side, which diminishes learning opportunities. The study concludes that while digitalization offers immediate benefits, it may hinder long-term learning and productivity gains. Future research should explore how firms can balance these effects and consider the implications for other forms of internationalization. This text was initially drafted using artificial intelligence, then reviewed by the author(s) to ensure accuracy . 关于新技术对企业的影响, 尤其是当它与国际化相联时, 长期存在着持续的争论。一些学者认为, 数字化将通过促进与合作伙伴及客户的联系来增强出口活动的收益。然而, 另一些学者则认为, 数字化根本无法达到其所被鼓吹的效果——甚至可能更糟。这一争论对中小企业 (SMEs) 尤为重要, 因为出口活动是此类企业进入全球市场的主要途径。我们提出, 数字化将对SME产生双重影响: 从“积极”的一面来看, 对数字技术的更大投资将带来更多的出口活动 (即更高的出口销售额) ; 然而, 从“消极”的一面来看, 由数字化引发的出口活动将从出口合作伙伴那里获得较少的学习机会 (即较小的生产率增益) 。我们使用2010至2019年间20,133家葡萄牙企业的详细企业层面面板数据, 对提出的假设进行了检验, 并得到了支持。额外的分析和案例研究进一步证实了所提出的机制, 并指出混合方法可能是平衡数字化双重影响的一种可行途径。综合来看, 这些发现为关于数字化在国际化进程中所起作用的讨论提供了新启示。 Les débats de longue date persistent quant à l'impact des nouvelles technologies sur les entreprises, en particulier en ce qui concerne l'internationalisation. Certains chercheurs suggèrent que la numérisation renforcera les avantages des activités d'exportation en facilitant les connexions avec les partenaires et les clients. D'autres, en revanche, estiment que la numérisation ne sera tout simplement pas à la hauteur des attentes, voire qu’elle aura des conséquences encore plus néfastes. Ce débat est particulièrement pertinent pour les PME, étant donné que l'activité d'exportation constitue pour elles la principale voie d'accès aux marchés mondiaux. Nous proposons que la numérisation exercera des effets doubles sur les PME : d'un côté « lumineux », des investissements plus importants dans les technologies numériques conduiront à une activité d'exportation accrue (c'est-à-dire des ventes à l'exportation plus élevées) ; d'un côté « sombre », cependant, l'activité d'exportation induite par la numérisation générera moins d'opportunités d'apprentissage auprès des partenaires d'exportation (c'est-à-dire des gains de productivité plus faibles). Les hypothèses proposées ont été testées et confirmées à l'aide de données détaillées au niveau de l’entreprise, issues d'un panel de 20133 entreprises portugaises entre 2010 et 2019. Des analyses supplémentaires et des études de cas corroborent les mécanismes proposés, et suggèrent des approches hybrides comme une solution possible pour équilibrer ces effets doubles de la numérisation. Ensemble, ces résultats apportent un éclairage nouveau sur le débat concernant le rôle de la numérisation dans les efforts d'internationalisation. Persisten los debates de larga data sobre el impacto de las nuevas tecnologías en las empresas, particularmente en lo que respecta a la internacionalización. Algunos académicos sugieren que la digitalización mejorará los beneficios de la actividad exportadora al facilitar las conexiones con socios y clientes. Otros, sin embargo, sugieren que la digitalización simplemente no estará a la altura de las expectativas, o quizás incluso generar efectos adversos. Este debate es especialmente relevante para las PYMES, dado que la actividad exportadora es la principal vía hacia los mercados globales para este tipo de empresas. Proponemos que la digitalización ejercerá efectos ambivalentes en las PYMES: por el lado “positivo”, mayores inversiones en tecnologías digitales conducirán a una mayor actividad exportadora (es decir, mayores ventas de exportación); por el lado “negativo”, sin embargo, la actividad exportadora inducida por la digitalización generará menos oportunidades de aprendizaje derivado de los socios internacionales en los mercados de exportación (es decir, menores ganancias en productividad). Las hipótesis propuestas fueron probadas y respaldadas utilizando datos detallados a nivel de empresa de un panel de 20.133 empresas portuguesas entre 2010 y 2019. Análisis adicionales y estudios de caso corroboran los mecanismos propuestos y señalan enfoques híbridos como una posible forma de equilibrar estos efectos ambivalentes de la digitalización. En conjunto, los hallazgos arrojan nueva luz sobre el debate en torno al papel de la digitalización en los esfuerzos de internacionalización.