Reef fish taxonomic and functional diversity respond differently to habitat degradation and protection
Abstract
Coral reef ecosystems are impacted by a myriad of human activities and influenced by complex interactions between habitat characteristics and environmental stressors, yet the relative influence of these factors on reef fish diversity remains unclear. Here, we examine the effects of coral species richness (SR), structural complexity, fishing pressure, human disturbance, marine protection and wave exposure on reef fish taxonomic and functional diversity in a multi-use marine protected area (MPA) in Raja Ampat, Indonesia. Using a structural equation modeling approach, we found that fish SR was strongly predicted by both coral SR and structural complexity, while fish functional dispersion (FDis) showed no significant relationship with these habitat variables and was elevated in reefs with higher relative dead coral cover. Fishing pressure, estimated based on accessibility and population density, was associated with lower fish FDis, lower reef structural complexity, and higher dead coral cover, and was indirectly associated with lower fish SR through pathways mediated by habitat variables. Human disturbance, as estimated via direct proximity to settlements, showed comparatively weak and largely non-significant associations with habitat and fish diversity variables. We found that marine protection mitigated the impact of fishing pressure on fish SR and supported more structurally complex reefs. We emphasize the need to understand the interactions between environmental stressors and habitat features when designing conservation strategies for complex and biodiverse coral reef ecosystems, particularly as human activities continue to impact coral reefs worldwide.