Subsistence before markets: poverty and agricultural commercialization in Republican China
Аннотация
Does poverty draw farmers into markets through distress sales, or constrain their participation by limiting marketable surplus? Using county-level data from John Lossing Buck’s Land Utilization in China surveys (1929–1933), we construct three measures of agricultural commercialization in Republican China. Across measures and specifications, commercialization is positively associated with farm productivity, and instrumental-variable estimates provide corroborative evidence in the same direction. Productivity is also positively associated with marketable surplus, measured both as a share of output and per capita. Taken together, these patterns are more consistent with a subsistence-constraint interpretation than with distress sales as the dominant explanation. The findings help reconcile competing interpretations of Republican China’s rural economy: markets were widespread, yet participation varied with the capacity to produce beyond subsistence. More broadly, they highlight productive capacity as an important condition for commercialization in poor agrarian economies.