From data deficiency to decision-making: using tracking data to plug evidence gaps for Pollack (Pollachius pollachius)

Stamp, T., Mawer, R., Conlon, R., Davies, P., Hall, A. E., Hyder, K., Morris, T., Nesbit, R., Osmond, T., Reynell, S. E. A., Renn, C., Rudd, H., Stewart, B. D., Sullivan, S., Thomas, S., Uren, D., Sheehan, E. V.
Movement Ecology · Springer Nature · 2026-11-19 · DOI: 10.1186/s40462-026-00701-6

Abstract

Background Fish tracking studies rarely translate into tangible management actions, however, have the potential to reveal critical insights into spatial ecology. Despite this, fisheries stock assessments often introduce assumptions on fish populations. This includes the unit stock theory, that assumes homogenous population metrics and movement characteristics within a defined stock boundary which can span expansive areas. Methods Using the data-poor and imperiled UK Pollack ( Pollachius pollachius ) fishery as a case study, we combined acoustic telemetry (n = 125) and mark-recapture (n = 46) to track movements over a 4-year study period to demonstrate variability in movement characteristics. Results Hierarchical cluster analysis based on four continuous space use metrics revealed two distinct behavioral contingents: highly resident individuals (mean residency index = 0.36 ± 0.04 SE; dispersal = 1.45 km ± 0.19) and more mobile, non-resident individuals (residency index = 0.10 ± <0.01 SE; dispersal = 5.7 km). These findings, together with broader research, indicate that Pollack displays partial nomadism or partial migration. Such behavioral diversity creates contingents with different vulnerabilities to environmental variability and fishing pressure, directly violating the core assumption of population homogeneity in traditional unit stock theory. Conclusions We conclude that fish tracking should be better incorporated as a standard tool in fisheries population assessments alongside genetic and abundance surveys. We however emphasize that careful methodological consideration is required in future fish tracking studies to overcome inherent biases introduced by different tracking techniques and study configurations.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles