Cross-border crowdfunding: an attention-based view
Abstract
This article explores how crowd attention on digital platforms, specifically crowdfunding, differs from traditional managerial attention in organizations. Unlike structured organizational attention, crowd attention is decentralized and emerges from user interactions. This study focuses on how informational cues in crowdfunding campaigns guide backer attention, especially for international campaigns. The research highlights the importance of global orientation and local engagement cues in attracting backers, considering cultural differences and campaign characteristics. This article uses data from Kickstarter, a leading crowdfunding platform, to analyze how backers decide to support international campaigns. The study examines campaign pitches, which are key communication tools for startups to convey their product's potential. The research identifies two main attention stimuli: global narrative (a campaign's broad, inclusive message) and backer-country focus (engagement with backers' home countries). The study uses content analysis to measure these stimuli and tests their effects on backer support. It also considers how these effects vary based on campaign type (culturally oriented or market-ready) and cultural differences between backers and campaigns. The study uses a two-stage estimation approach to control for backers' propensity to support international campaigns. The results show that both global narrative and backer-country focus significantly increase the likelihood of backer support for international campaigns. These effects are stronger for culturally oriented and market-ready campaigns. Cultural differences between backers and campaigns further enhance the positive effects of these attention stimuli. The study concludes that attention stimuli in campaign pitches are crucial for attracting backers, especially in a crowded digital environment. It highlights the role of cultural differences as a potential amplifier of attention, rather than a barrier. The findings suggest that entrepreneurs can strategically design campaign pitches to capture global and local attention, and that crowdfunding platforms can enhance these effects through algorithmic features. Future research could explore attention mechanisms in other digital contexts and further investigate the role of cultural differences in international transactions. This text was initially drafted using artificial intelligence, then reviewed by the author(s) to ensure accuracy. Este estudio desarrolla una perspectiva basada en la atención sobre el crowdfunding transfronterizo, examinando cómo las señales informativas en las narrativas de las campañas guían la atención de los patrocinadores y sus decisiones de financiamiento. El crowdfunding permite un alcance global, pero intensifica la competencia por la limitada atención de los patrocinadores. Ampliando la perspectiva basada en la atención desde el ámbito gerencial en entornos organizacionales hacia la atención colectiva en plataformas digitales, conceptualizamos la atención colectiva como descentralizada y guiada por estímulos. Identificamos dos señales informativas clave como estímulos de atención: la narrativa global (relevancia universal) y el enfoque en el país del patrocinador (compromiso localizado). Argumentamos que estas señales aumentan el apoyo a las campañas internacionales, pero que sus efectos dependen de las características de la campaña, como su orientación cultural y su preparación para el mercado, las cuales se alinean con diferentes motivaciones de los patrocinadores. Además, proponemos que las diferencias culturales amplifican, en lugar de obstaculizar, la capacidad de respuesta de los patrocinadores a los estímulos de atención. Utilizando datos a gran escala de Kickstarter, encontramos evidencia que respalda nuestros argumentos y demostramos cómo las narrativas digitales moldean la atención y las decisiones de financiamiento en los intercambios transfronterizos. 本研究通过考察众筹项目叙述中的信息线索如何引导资助者的注意力与资助决策,开发了一种基于注意力的跨境众筹视角。众筹虽然能够实现全球覆盖,但加剧了对有限的资助者注意力的竞争。本文将基于注意力的视角从组织环境中的管理注意力扩展到数字平台上的大众注意力,将大众注意力概念化为去中心化且由刺激驱动的注意力。我们确定了作为注意力刺激因素的两类关键的信息线索:全球叙述(普遍相关性)和受资助国聚焦(本地化参与)。我们认为,这些线索能够增加对国际项目的支持,但其效果取决于项目特征,例如文化导向和市场准备度,这些特征与不同资助者的动机相契合。我们进一步提出,文化差异会放大而非削弱资助者对注意力刺激的反应。通过使用大规模的Kickstarter数据,我们找到了支持我们论点的证据,并展示了数字叙述如何在跨境交换中塑造注意力与资助决策。 This study develops an attention-based view of cross-border crowdfunding by examining how informational cues in campaign narratives guide backers’ attention and funding decisions. Crowdfunding enables global reach but intensifies competition for limited backer attention. Extending the attention-based view from managerial attention in organizational settings to crowd attention on digital platforms, we conceptualize crowd attention as decentralized and stimulus-driven. We identify two key informational cues as attention stimuli: global narrative (universal relevance) and backer-country focus (localized engagement). We argue that these cues increase support for international campaigns but that their effects depend on campaign characteristics such as cultural orientation and market readiness, which align with different backer motives. We further propose that cultural differences amplify, rather than hinder, backers’ responsiveness to attention stimuli. Using large-scale Kickstarter data, we find support for our arguments and demonstrate how digital narratives shape attention and funding decisions in cross-border exchanges. Este estudo desenvolve uma visão baseada na atenção sobre o crowdfunding transfronteiriço, examinando como pistas informacionais nas narrativas de campanhas orientam a atenção dos apoiadores e suas decisões de financiamento. O crowdfunding permite um alcance global, mas intensifica a competição pela atenção limitada de apoiadores. Ampliando a visão baseada na atenção — da atenção gerencial em contextos organizacionais à atenção da multidão em plataformas digitais —, conceitualizamos a atenção da multidão como descentralizada e impulsionada por estímulos. Identificamos dois principais rastros informacionais como estímulos de atenção: a narrativa global (relevância universal) e o foco no país do apoiador (engajamento localizado). Argumentamos que esses rastros aumentam o apoio a campanhas internacionais, mas que seus efeitos dependem de características das campanhas, como orientação cultural e prontidão de mercado, que se alinham a diferentes motivações dos apoiadores. Propomos ainda que as diferenças culturais amplificam, em vez de inibir, a capacidade dos apoiadores de responder a estímulos de atenção. Utilizando dados em larga escala do Kickstarter, encontramos evidências que sustentam nossos argumentos e demonstramos como narrativas digitais moldam a atenção e as decisões de financiamento em trocas transfronteiriças. Cette recherche développe une approche du financement participatif transfrontalier axée sur l'attention en examinant comment les indices informationnels présents dans les récits des campagnes orientent l’attention des contributeurs et influencent leurs décisions de financement. Le financement participatif permet une portée mondiale, mais intensifie la concurrence pour capter l’attention limitée des contributeurs. En élargissant la perspective basée sur l’attention, qui s'applique initialement à l'attention managériale dans les contextes organisationnels, à l’attention de la foule sur les plateformes numériques, nous conceptualisons l’attention de la foule comme décentralisée et guidée par les stimuli. Nous identifions deux indices informationnels clés comme stimuli d’attention : le récit global (pertinence universelle) et l’accent mis sur le pays des contributeurs (engagement localisé). Nous argumentons que ces indices augmentent le soutien aux campagnes internationales, mais que leurs impacts dépendent des caractéristiques des campagnes, telles que l’orientation culturelle et la maturité du marché, qui correspondent à différentes motivations des contributeurs. Nous avançons en outre l'hypothèse selon laquelle les différences culturelles renforcent, plutôt qu'elles n'entravent, la réceptivité des contributeurs face aux stimuli d'attention. À partir d'une analyse à grande échelle des données de Kickstarter, nous étayons nos arguments, et démontrons comment les récits numériques influencent l'attention et les décisions de financement dans le cadre d'échanges transfrontaliers.