Theory without method, method without theory: a bibliometric-TCCM synthesis of the ESG, greenwashing and capital-market efficiency literature
Аннотация
This study examines how research on ESG data quality, greenwashing and capital-market efficiency has evolved, with particular attention to the development of theory, geographic and contextual coverage, methodological choices and the integration of capital-market frictions. It asks: (i) how has the literature developed over time; (ii) to what extent are theoretical, contextual and methodological perspectives integrated; and (iii) which intersections remain underexplored for understanding ESG information and capital-market outcomes? To address these questions, the study synthesises 1472 Scopus-indexed journal articles published between 2015 and 2026 using bibliometric mapping and a Theory–Context–Characteristics–Methodology (TCCM) review. Titles and abstracts were coded using transparent, rule-based procedures supported by documented keyword dictionaries, cleaning rules and R code, with independent blind validation to assess coding reliability across theory, context and methodology categories. Five findings emerge. First, the field has expanded rapidly, progressing from a foundational phase (2015–2017) through a period of ESG rating divergence (2018–2021) to an ISSB/AI acceleration phase (2022–2026). Second, theoretical engagement remains limited; only 14.1% of titles and abstracts explicitly identify a theory, whereas 52.4% contain no identifiable theoretical cue. Third, quantitative archival research dominates the field (77.7%), while NLP and machine learning studies account for 7.3% and are expanding rapidly without a corresponding increase in theoretical visibility. Fourth, the literature is geographically concentrated in Asia (61.5%), particularly China (39.5%), while 88.0% of author affiliations are Asian, revealing substantial Affiliate–Context Decoupling. Fifth, capital-market frictions remain weakly integrated, with financing-friction language appearing in only 11.5% of abstracts and monetary-policy channels being virtually absent. The resulting TCCM gap matrices identify underexplored theory–context–methodology intersections. The study contributes an operational measure of Affiliate–Context Decoupling, reproducible Theory×Methodology and Theory×Context matrices, a capital-market-frictions lens and an Integrated ESG Information Market Model. These insights provide directions for future research and have implications for investors, regulators and standard-setters responding to ISSB IFRS S1/S2 and the EU CSRD.