The International Sports Law Journal Гуманитарные и социальные науки

Toward comparative negligence: Coordinating the application of the assumption of risk rule in minors’ sports injury cases in China

Li, Shuqi, Nai, Peng, Yang, JingHan
Springer Nature · 2026-11-07 · DOI 10.1007/s40318-026-00358-8

Аннотация

For the first time, China’s Civil Code expressly incorporates the assumption of risk rule into statutory law, providing a new normative framework for risk allocation and liability determination in sports injury cases, while also bringing into sharper relief the tensions among different liability rules in judicial application. An empirical analysis of 136 relevant judicial decisions shows that judicial practice does not simply follow the “complete exemption” logic of assumption of risk; rather, different adjudicative approaches can be observed in the selection and application of legal rules and the allocation of liability in individual cases. Based on these findings, this study proposes a “toward comparative negligence” framework for coordinating the application of relevant rules. Specifically, the conditions for applying the assumption of risk rule should be further clarified and restricted; the standards governing the duty of care owed by sports activity organizers should be reasonably delineated; the residual application of the fairness-based loss-sharing rule should be strictly confined; and judicial discretion should be appropriately constrained. On this basis, the assumption of risk rule and the comparative negligence rule should be systematically coordinated, with the respective degrees of fault of both the actor and the injured party comprehensively assessed to achieve a more refined and reasonable allocation of liability.

Читать у издателя →