Environmental Economics and Policy Studies Управление, мониторинг, политика и право в экологии
Enhancing collective action: a comparative study of online versus face-to-face team activities in a public bads game
Аннотация
Collective action problems arise when individuals pursue private gains at the expense of shared welfare. While team-building promotes cooperation in public goods settings, its efficacy in public bad environments—where cooperation requires restraint—remains underexplored. This study investigates how the medium of interaction impacts the formation of team identity and subsequent restraint. In a controlled laboratory experiment, 120 university students repeatedly made investment decisions in a public bad game. To isolate the causal effect of communication channels, participants were randomly assigned to one of three pre-task treatments: individual activity (baseline), online team-building, or face-to-face team-building via a collaborative puzzle task. Analysis using a mixed-effects model reveals that face-to-face team-building significantly reduced investment in the public bad game, yielding sustained cooperation over time. In contrast, online team-building produced only modest and temporary effects. Furthermore, participants adjusted their behavior based on the relative peer positioning rather than group averages, highlighting the critical role of localized social comparison. Finally, prosocial orientation, female gender, and regular religious engagement were found to be associated with stronger cooperative tendencies. These findings provide foundational causal evidence on how interaction mediums shape collective restraint, offering suggestive baseline insights for designing real-world interventions to mitigate negative externalities.