Limited effects of landscape-scale protection netting on bird assemblages in unnetted apple orchards

Cell and Tissue Biology · Springer Nature · 2026-09-22 · DOI: 10.1007/s13593-026-01139-1

Аннотация

Modern agricultural intensification has contributed to widespread biodiversity decline in agricultural landscapes, with important implications for bird populations. Apple orchards can support diverse bird assemblages in southeastern France, but increased use of protective netting as an alternative to insecticides and as a protection against climatic hazards raises questions about its ecological effects at the landscape scale. We evaluated the effects of landscape-scale netting on bird assemblages and functional groups in unnetted organic apple orchards in southeastern France, distinguishing between nets enclosing single-row trees and nets covering whole orchards. Bird assemblages were surveyed in 29 orchards along a landscape gradient of netting coverage. The local density of extensive hedgerows was considered as a covariate due to its expected influence on bird assemblages. Landscape-scale netting had no significant effect on overall bird abundance and species richness. Insectivorous species showed a limited negative response to landscape-scale netting, being positively associated with the landscape-scale proportion of unnetted orchards but not with total orchard cover. Species-specific responses were detected: The Eurasian blackcap ( Sylvia atricapilla ) increased only with the area of unnetted orchards, whereas the Eurasian blackbird ( Turdus merula ) responded negatively to single-row netting. The other abundant species were unaffected. Extensively managed hedgerows had strong positive effects on bird assemblages, highlighting their importance in supporting bird communities in agricultural landscapes. Our results indicate for the first time that netting, while protecting orchards against pests—thus facilitating their conversion to organic management—and climatic hazards, had limited effects at the community level in unnetted orchards surrounded by extensive hedgerows. It may, however, have influenced some species through landscape-scale processes, highlighting the importance of species-specific responses and of the landscape scale when evaluating the ecological effects of agricultural practices.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи