International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education Education

Examining Students’ Mathematical Reasoning Within and Across Paper-and-Pencil, Dynamic Geometry, and Text-Based Programming Environments: The Case of Linear Inequalities and Linear Programming

Jietong Luo, Oi-Lam Ng, Huiyan Ye
Springer Nature · 2026-10-01 · DOI 10.1007/s10763-026-10737-0

Abstract

Abstract As an important skill in secondary mathematics, mathematical reasoning (MR) demonstrates distinct features within paper-and-pencil and tool-based environments, highlighting the affordances and limitations of the tools used. This indicates the necessity to investigate students’ MR among different environments to facilitate students’ learning. To this end, this study examines students’ MR within and across three environments: paper-and-pencil (PPE), dynamic geometry (DGE) and text-based programming environments (TPE), focusing on tasks involving (systems of) linear inequalities and linear programming. Through task-based interviews with three high school students and from the lens of instrumental genesis, we observe students’ unique features of MR within one environment, as well as transition and translation of MR across different environments. Furthermore, students’ different types of instrumentalisation and instrumentation are identified within and across the three environments: (a) various forms of personalisation within the tool-based environments; (b) two schemes involving mathematical and programming knowledge for managing the internal constraints in the TPE; and (c) two schemes developed from students’ particular selection of the tool functions within DGE. The theory-informed findings lay the groundwork for future research on integrating multiple resources and exploiting their affordances to enhance mathematics instruction.

Read at publisher →