Saving or Investing for the Future? Methodology Matters in Inclusive Wealth Accounting

International Journal of Anthropology and Ethnology · Springer Nature · 2026-09-10 · DOI: 10.1007/s10640-026-01115-z

Аннотация

At the 57th session of the UN Statistical Commission, methodological guidelines for wealth accounting were identified as a priority for the Beyond GDP agenda. Our paper contributes directly to this need. Genuine Savings (GS), a leading sustainable development indicator in environmental and resource economics, measures changes in inclusive wealth by adjusting national savings for natural capital depletion, physical capital depreciation, and human capital investment. An unappreciated issue is that the distinction between savings-based (GS) and investment-based (GI) measures is treated as semantic. In theory, both are identical given the savings-investment identity underpinning the national accounts. In practice, this identity does not always hold, due to statistical discrepancies and accounting revisions, with the savings side particularly susceptible. This paper is the first to examine how savings-investment discrepancies in the national accounts affect practical wealth accounting. Using data for thirty-three countries and two datasets (World Bank and AMECO), we show that GS and GI disagree, within and across datasets, by more than double the natural capital adjustment itself, enough to generate conflicting sustainability signals in both level and direction of change. These issues are persistent in the World Bank data, the primary global dataset for wealth accounting, while AMECO is largely internally consistent after 1995. Structural break analysis suggests supply and use balancing under the ESA95 revisions, together with reconciliation of the current account balance, reduces the disagreement. We provide practical guidance, including a formal GS-GI distinction, routine savings-investment consistency checks, a more central role for national statistics offices, and an uncertainty band of 3 percentage points of GNI to replace the binary zero threshold.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи