Semiotic Individuality in Lichen Symbioses: An Operational Framework
Аннотация
Lichens challenge biological individuality because an organised thallus can unite partners with distinct genomes, life histories, and degrees of autonomy. Their taxonomic heterogeneity and within-thallus photobiont plurality also challenge any uniform attribution of consortium-level agency. I propose semiotic individuality as a complementary dimension of individuality: the degree to which a specified consortium maintains mediated, context-sensitive relations organised with respect to its continued functioning. The framework distinguishes the semiotic self as a locus of system-relative significance, the semiotic agent as an organisation acting through such relations, and semiotic individuality as a question about the scale, boundaries, and persistence of that organisation. Peircean sign–object–interpretant relations guide the identification of mediation, while Barbieri’s work clarifies both the compatibility of molecular mechanism with semiotic explanation and the distinct evidential demands of organic coding. Four operational dimensions are retained: context sensitivity, norm-guided correction, relational persistence, and remapping. Five empirical domains connect these dimensions to lichen research without treating interaction, chemical inhibition, photobiont coexistence, or community turnover as sufficient evidence of semiosis. Comparisons include mechanistic models with memory and feedback, alongside deliberately restricted baselines. Existing studies provide empirical footholds; they do not yet validate the complete profile in any lichen. The contribution is a conditional programme for locating and testing semiotic organisation across symbiotic partners and scales, with explicit conditions for weakening or withholding higher-order agency.