Plant Biosystems Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics
Tree species identity and canopy structure are associated with long-term understory diversity 75 years after post-fire reforestation in Türkiye
Abstract
This study aimed to determine how tree species identity and canopy structure are associated with long-term understory diversity 75 years after post-fire reforestation by testing differences in understory richness and composition among plantation stands composed of native and non-native tree species, and the response of Cistus laurifolius cover to canopy openness and light availability. Forty 2 × 2 m subplots were sampled within eight historical experimental plots (P1–P8) of varying present-day dimensions, nested in three historical blocks (B1–B3), representing stands of Pinus sylvestris , Abies nordmanniana subsp. e qui-trojani , and Cedrus libani , and compared with the adjacent native Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana stands. Canopy cover, species richness (α-diversity), beta diversity, and species–environment relationships were evaluated along a canopy-related light gradient using Detrended Correspondence Analysis (DCA) and correlation analysis. Dense Abies nordmanniana subsp. e qui-trojani stands with 88–97% canopy closure exhibited markedly reduced understory diversity, with only 24 recorded species and 3.2–7.0 species per 4 m² across Blocks B1 and B2, and were dominated by shade-tolerant species associated with low-light, mesic conditions. In contrast, Pinus sylvestris, Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana and Cedrus libani stands showed higher species richness (36–43 species), although compositional heterogeneity varied among stand types. Beta diversity varied substantially among stand types, with the highest values observed in Abies nordmanniana subsp. e qui-trojani (1.57–2.44) and Cedrus libani (1.95), whereas Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana and Pinus sylvestris showed comparatively lower beta diversity (0.96–1.10 and 1.16–1.38, respectively). DCA revealed pronounced species turnover along the primary ordination gradient (4.13 SD). The abundance of Cistus laurifolius declined significantly with increasing canopy closure ( r = −0.38, p = 0.015). These findings suggest that post-fire reforestation can leave persistent ecological legacies, with tree species identity and associated differences in canopy structure and light availability contributing to long-term variation in understory diversity and composition. The persistence of Cistus laurifolius further reflects its association with canopy development and post-fire succession. Collectively, these results suggest that tree species selection and structural heterogeneity should be considered in biodiversity-oriented restoration beyond the re-establishment of tree cover.