Withering sustainability? The rise (and fall?) of sustainability due diligence

Marx, Axel
Journal of International Business Policy · Springer Nature · 2026-06-01 · DOI: 10.1057/s42214-026-00248-8

Аннотация

The concept of sustainable development emerged in the late twentieth century due to concerns about the environmental and social impacts of rapid economic growth. Reports like “The Limits to Growth” and “Our Common Future” highlighted the need for balancing development with environmental preservation. This led to the creation of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in 2015, which emphasized sustainability in economic, social, and environmental dimensions. In Europe, the European Green Deal and other initiatives imposed sustainability due diligence obligations on companies, requiring them to address challenges like climate change and unfair working conditions. However, as these regulations were being codified, political resistance emerged, challenging the sustainability agenda and signaling a shift in how sustainability will be governed globally. This article explores the rise of sustainability due diligence, particularly in Europe. It discusses how businesses initially engaged with sustainability through voluntary initiatives like the UN Global Compact. However, voluntary approaches often fell short, leading to the development of mandatory due diligence obligations. These obligations require companies to identify and mitigate risks related to human rights and the environment throughout their value chains. The article highlights various international standards and laws, such as the French Duty of Vigilance Law and the EU's Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD), which aim to enforce these obligations. The CSDDD, adopted in 2024, was initially ambitious, covering many companies and requiring comprehensive due diligence. However, political debates and resistance have led to a weakened version, reducing the number of companies in scope and the extent of due diligence required. The results indicate a significant shift in corporate sustainability governance, moving from voluntary to mandatory approaches. This shift aims to level the playing field among companies and align various sustainability initiatives. However, recent political resistance and deregulation pressures threaten to undermine these advancements. The article concludes that while mandatory due diligence represents progress, the current political climate poses challenges to its implementation. Future implications include the need for businesses to navigate a fragmented regulatory landscape and the potential for sustainability to become a strategic challenge rather than just a compliance issue. This text was initially drafted using artificial intelligence, then reviewed by the author(s) to ensure accuracy. O artigo examina a ascensão e a recente contestação da due diligence (diligência previa, em português) em sustentabilidade como um novo instrumento de política para regulamentar a conduta corporativa em cadeias de valor globais. Emergindo de décadas de iniciativas voluntárias de sustentabilidade, a due diligence evoluiu para uma abordagem regulatória que traduz compromissos internacionais em relação à sustentabilidade diretamente em obrigações corporativas, permitindo que os reguladores exerçam sua autoridade além das fronteiras. Esses desenvolvimentos pareciam constituir uma mudança significativa na governança da sustentabilidade, possibilitando a busca por políticas de “combinação inteligente” que unem instrumentos de governança públicos e privados. No entanto, tensões geopolíticas crescentes e pressões desregulamentadoras desencadearam uma resistência política significativa contra a regulamentação da sustentabilidade. O artigo ilustra essa resistência ao focar na Diretiva de Due Diligence em Sustentabilidade Corporativa da UE (União Europeia), que foi substancialmente enfraquecida. O artigo argumenta que esse retrocesso pode comprometer os objetivos de sustentabilidade de longo prazo e colocar as empresas em um ambiente regulatório cada vez mais complexo. Ele conclui delineando as implicações para os negócios internacionais e reflexões sobre a ordem internacional liberal em um contexto pós-globalização. The paper examines the rise and recent contestation of sustainability due diligence as a new policy instrument for governing corporate conduct in global value chains. Emerging from decades of voluntary sustainability initiatives, due diligence has evolved into a regulatory approach that translates international commitments with regard to sustainability directly into corporate obligations, enabling regulators to govern across borders. These developments appeared to constitute a significant shift in sustainability governance enabling the further pursuit of “smart mix” policies which combine public and private governance instruments. Yet, mounting geopolitical tensions and deregulatory pressures have triggered significant political pushback against sustainability regulation. The paper illustrates this pushback by focusing on the EU’s Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive which has been substantially weakened. The paper argues that this retrenchment risks undermining long-term sustainability objectives and placing firms in an increasingly complex regulatory environment. It concludes by outlining implications for international business and reflections on the liberal international order in a post-globalization context. El artículo examina el auge y la reciente controversia en torno a la debida diligencia en sostenibilidad como un nuevo instrumento político para regular la conducta corporativa en las cadenas de valor globales. Surgiendo de décadas de iniciativas voluntarias de sostenibilidad, la debida diligencia ha evolucionado hacia un enfoque regulatorio que traduce los compromisos internacionales en materia de sostenibilidad directamente en obligaciones corporativas, permitiendo a los reguladores gobernar más allá de las fronteras. Estos desarrollos parecían constituir un cambio significativo en la gobernanza de la sostenibilidad, permitiendo la búsqueda adicional de políticas de “mezcla inteligente” que combinan instrumentos de gobernanza pública y privada. Sin embargo, las crecientes tensiones geopolíticas y las presiones desreguladoras han desencadenado una significativa resistencia política contra la regulación de la sostenibilidad. El artículo ilustra esta resistencia centrándose en la Directiva de Debida Diligencia en Sostenibilidad Corporativa de la UE, que ha sido sustancialmente debilitada. El artículo argumenta que este retroceso pone en riesgo los objetivos de sostenibilidad a largo plazo y sitúa a las empresas en un entorno regulatorio cada vez más complejo. Concluye delineando las implicaciones para los negocios internacionales y reflexionando sobre el orden internacional liberal en un contexto de posglobalización. Dieses Papier untersucht den Aufstieg und die jüngste Anfechtung der Nachhaltigkeits-Sorgfaltspflicht als ein neues politisches Instrument zur Regulierung des unternehmerischen Verhaltens in globalen Wertschöpfungsketten. Aus Jahrzehnten freiwilliger Nachhaltigkeitsinitiativen hervorgegangen, hat sich die Sorgfaltspflicht zu einem regulatorischen Ansatz entwickelt, der internationale Bestrebungen in Bezug auf Nachhaltigkeit direkt in unternehmerische Pflichten übersetzt und es den Regulierungsbehörden ermöglicht, über Grenzen hinweg zu steuern. Diese Entwicklungen schienen einen bedeutenden Wandel in der Nachhaltigkeitssteuerung darzustellen, der die weitere Verfolgung von „Smart-Mix“-Maßnahmen ermöglicht, welche öffentliche und private Steuerungsinstrumente kombinieren. Doch zunehmende geopolitische Spannungen und deregulierungspolitische Bestrebungen haben erheblichen politischen Druck gegen die Nachhaltigkeitsregulierung ausgelöst. Das Papier veranschaulicht diesen Gegendruck, indem es sich auf die EU-Richtlinie zur unternehmerischen Sorgfaltspflicht im Bereich der Nachhaltigkeit konzentriert, die erheblich abgeschwächt wurde. Das Papier argumentiert, dass dieser Rückschritt das Risiko birgt, langfristige Nachhaltigkeitsziele zu untergraben und Unternehmen in ein zunehmend komplexes regulatorisches Umfeld zu versetzen. Abschließend skizziert es die Implikationen für internationale Unternehmen und reflektiert über die liberale internationale Ordnung in einem post-globalisierten Kontext. 本文探讨了可持续性尽职调查, 作为一种在全球价值链中治理企业行为的新型政策工具, 的兴起及其近期的争议。这一工具源于数十年的自愿性可持续发展倡议, 尽职调查已经演变为一种监管方法, 将与可持续性相关的国际承诺直接转化为企业义务, 从而使监管者能够跨越国界进行治理。这些发展似乎构成了可持续性治理的一个重要转变, 进一步推动了“智能组合”政策的实施, 即结合公共和私人治理工具的政策。然而, 日益加剧的地缘政治紧张局势和放松管制的压力引发了对可持续性监管的显著政治反弹。本文通过聚焦欧盟已被大幅削弱的《企业可持续性尽职调查指令》来说明这种反弹。本文认为, 这种倒退可能会削弱长期的可持续性目标, 并使企业面临日益复杂的监管环境。最后, 本文总结了对国际商务的影响, 并反映了后全球化背景下自由国际秩序的相关问题。 L’article examine l’essor et la contestation récente de la diligence raisonnable en matière de durabilité en tant que nouvel instrument de politique publique visant à encadrer la conduite des entreprises dans les chaînes de valeur mondiales. Issu de décennies d’initiatives volontaires en matière de durabilité, le concept de diligence raisonnable a évolué vers une approche réglementaire qui traduit directement les engagements internationaux en matière de durabilité en obligations pour les entreprises, permettant ainsi aux régulateurs d’exercer une gouvernance au-delà des frontières nationales. Ces évolutions semblaient constituer un changement significatif dans la gouvernance de la durabilité, ouvrant la voie à un renforcement des politiques de «mix intelligent », combinant des instruments de gouvernance publics et privés. Toutefois, la montée des tensions géopolitiques et les pressions en faveur de la déréglementation ont suscité une importante contestation politique à l’encontre de la réglementation en matière de durabilité. L’article illustre cette contestation en se concentrant sur la directive européenne relative au devoir de diligence des entreprises en matière de durabilité, qui a été substantiellement affaiblie. L’article soutient que ce recul risque de compromettre les objectifs de durabilité à long terme et de placer les entreprises dans un environnement réglementaire de plus en plus complexe. Il conclut en exposant les implications pour les affaires internationales et en proposant des réflexions sur l’ordre international libéral dans un contexte de post-mondialisation.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи