Journal of Business Logistics Management Science and Operations Research
Pulling Back the Curtain: Using Dependability, Credibility, Transferability, and Confirmability as Evaluation Criteria for Literature Reviews
Abstract
ABSTRACT Literature review articles play a crucial role in advancing knowledge by making sense of a body of research and setting a foundation for subsequent inquiry. Because much of the work is unobservable, some readers may wonder about the underlying rigor of a literature review. This hidden element creates parallels between literature reviews and qualitative research. In response to concerns about rigor, qualitative researchers have developed and rely upon a set of criteria by which qualitative work can be judged. In this essay, we adapt those criteria—dependability (analogous to reliability), credibility (analogous to internal validity), transferability (analogous to external validity), and confirmability (analogous to objectivity)—and explain how the criteria can be used to assess and improve the rigor of literature review articles. We then introduce the 2026 Special Topic Forum articles and spotlight examples wherein the articles excelled along the evaluation criteria.